Skip to content

I will survive! But how will I live?

June 28, 2013

Report: A minimum income standard for the United Kingdom in 2013

If you were trying to establish the minimum housing space that families require in Britain today, how useful do you think it would be to see how many people you could fit into a red telephone box? This may seem a really stupid question. But it pretty much equates to what various journalists have been doing in recent months when they challenge themselves to survive on a few pounds a day, and think that this will help inform the welfare debate.

Such exercises are misguided because the big question about minimum acceptable living standards in Britain today is not what you need in order to stay alive. Failing to die of malnutrition is very different from living life at an acceptable level. This is well understood by members of the public, even if not by journalists. The people taking part in our research, on what people think constitutes a minimum acceptable income standard for the UK, readily understand the distinction. One participant articulated it succinctly: “food and shelter keeps you alive: it doesn’t make you live”.

All this helps explain why there’s no contradiction between being able to live on £53 a week (“if I had to, I would”: IDS) and needing  over three times that amount to live at an acceptable level as defined by members of the public (our latest Minimum Income Standard update). The £71.70 that Income Support pays remains woefully inadequate. It is simply not possible to live adequately on £10 a day, week in week out, to cover short and long term expenses including food, gas bills, electricity bills, water bills, clothes, shoes, toothpaste, a sofa, cooking utensils, a washing machine, a wardrobe, plates, haircuts,  a fridge, toilet paper, a computer, an internet connection, bus fares, a TV license and all those dozens of other items that most of us take for granted as regular payments essential for everyday living.

It would be futile to suggest that the £71.70 Income Support level should be increased overnight to £185, the amount needed to buy all these things according to the research. But the yawning gap between what benefits pay and what people really need in order to afford the essentials of life is at the very least an argument against making things even worse. In April, the worst-off people in Britain faced the first explicit absolute cut in their living standards since the 1930s, as the government cut the link between inflation and benefit upratings. All sorts of political justifications have been given for this, but the evidence clearly puts the lie to the idea that people can live at a perfectly acceptable level on the levels that our social “safety net” currently provides.

Advertisements
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: